Reasonably Foreseeable Involves Remoteness Principles Regarding a View to Risk of Harm - 2027 | Vagans Legal


Last Updated: , 76 days ago.

Question:How do foreseeability and remoteness principles affect whether a negligence claim in Ontario can succeed?

Answer:Vagans Legal explains that, in negligence cases, reasonable foreseeability asks whether a reasonable person in the defendant’s position ought to have anticipated that their conduct could possibly (and as a real risk, not far-fetched) lead to the type of harm the plaintiff suffered, using an objective test focused on what could be foreseen before the incident, not hindsight; remoteness then asks whether the actual harm is too unrelated to the wrongful conduct to fairly hold the defendant liable, so even if some harm was foreseeable, the specific injury must not be outside the scope of what is fairly attributable.   If you’re assessing liability or damages in Ontario, a paralegal from Vagans Legal can help you map the facts to these legal tests and organize your next steps without delays, call (416) 473-8472.

Add this website to Google Preferred Sources


When Foreseeability Is Referred to Within a Negligence Lawsuit, What Does Foreseeability Mean?

The Question of Foreseeability Requires a Review of Whether An Incident Resulting in Harm Was Something That a Reasonable Person Could Think of as Having Possibility of Occurring.

Note: For immediate help, please contact Vagans Legal by phone at: (416) 473-8472 to retain services or to discuss any specific questions that you may have.


Understanding Reasonable Foreseeability Including Remoteness Principles Regarding Risk of Causing Harm

Reasonably Foreseeable Involves Remoteness Principles Regarding a View to Risk of Harm Negligence law includes the principle of reasonable foreseeability.  Reasonable foreseeability involves the question of whether a reasonable person could envision the risk of harm arising from the specific conduct in question.  As a fundamental component of negligence law principles requires an analysis of what a reasonable person would do or avoid doing, analyzing what a reasonable person would view as risky becomes necessary within a negligence liability discussion.

The Law

Within the Rankin (Rankin’s Garage & Sales) v. J.J., [2018] 1 S.C.R. 587, and Mustapha v. Culligan of Canada Ltd., [2008] 2 S.C.R. 114, cases, the Supreme Court explained the concept of reasonable foreseeability whereas it was said:


[53]  Whether or not something is “reasonably foreseeable” is an objective test. The analysis is focussed on whether someone in the defendant’s position ought reasonably to have foreseen the harm rather than whether the specific defendant did. Courts should be vigilant in ensuring that the analysis is not clouded by the fact that the event in question actually did occur. The question is properly focussed on whether foreseeability was present prior to the incident occurring and not with the aid of 20/20 hindsight: L. N. Klar and C.S.G. Jefferies, Tort Law (6th ed. 2017), at p. 212.


[12]  The remoteness inquiry asks whether “the harm [is] too unrelated to the wrongful conduct to hold the defendant fairly liable” (Linden and Feldthusen, at p. 360). Since The Wagon Mound (No. 1), the principle has been that “it is the foresight of the reasonable man which alone can determine responsibility” (Overseas Tankship (U.K.) Ltd. v. Morts Dock & Engineering Co., [1961] A.C. 388 (P.C.), at p. 424).

[13]  Much has been written on how probable or likely a harm needs to be in order to be considered reasonably foreseeable. The parties raise the question of whether a reasonably foreseeable harm is one whose occurrence is probable or merely possible. In my view, these terms are misleading. Any harm which has actually occurred is “possible”; it is therefore clear that possibility alone does not provide a meaningful standard for the application of reasonable foreseeability. The degree of probability that would satisfy the reasonable foreseeability requirement was described in The Wagon Mound (No. 2) as a “real risk”, i.e. “one which would occur to the mind of a reasonable man in the position of the defendan[t] . . . and which he would not brush aside as far-fetched” (Overseas Tankship (U.K.) Ltd. v. Miller Steamship Co. Pty., [1967] A.C. 617 (P.C.), at p. 643).

[14]  The remoteness inquiry depends not only upon the degree of probability required to meet the reasonable foreseeability requirement, but also upon whether or not the plaintiff is considered objectively or subjectively. One of the questions that arose in this case was whether, in judging whether the personal injury was foreseeable, one looks at a person of “ordinary fortitude” or at a particular plaintiff with his or her particular vulnerabilities.  This question may be acute in claims for mental injury, since there is a wide variation in how particular people respond to particular stressors.  The law has consistently held — albeit within the duty of care analysis — that the question is what a person of ordinary fortitude would suffer: see White v. Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police, [1998] 3 W.L.R. 1509 (H.L.); Devji v. Burnaby (District) (1999), 180 D.L.R. (4th) 205, 1999 BCCA 599; Vanek.  As stated in White, at p. 1512: “The law expects reasonable fortitude and robustness of its citizens and will not impose liability for the exceptional frailty of certain individuals.”

The Rankin and Mustapha cases explainl foreseeability as pertaining to whether a person could reasonably anticipate that specific behavior might cause harm to some other person.  Moreover, according to the principles established in Rankin and Mustapha, when evaluating whether harm was foreseeable, a court should approach the situation from the perspective of foresight before the incident occurred rather than in hindsight after the incident occurred.

Summary Comment

Negligence law involves the scrutiny of whether an individual acted without proper care and should be held accountable for the harm caused to another person. A component of the scrutiny into whether actions were without proper care involves the inquiry into whether the harm caused could be rationally seen as a possibility.  If the harm was reasonably unforeseeable, then liability for the harm fails to arise.

At
Our Desk Now!
Need Help? Let's Get Started Today

NOTE: Do not send confidential information through the web form.  Use the web form only for your introduction.   Learn Why?
8

NOTE: A significant number of online searches featuring “lawyers near me” or “best lawyer in” frequently indicate an urgent need for effective legal assistance rather than a particular title.  In Ontario, licensed paralegals are governed by the same Law Society that regulates lawyers and hold the authority to represent clients in specified litigation issues.  Core to their role are advocacy, legal analysis, and a mastery of procedures.  Vagans Legal provides legal representation within its licensed framework, focusing on strategic positioning, preparation of evidentiary materials, and compelling advocacy designed to secure efficient and favourable outcomes for clients.

AR, BN, CA+|EN, DT, ES, FA, FR, GU, HE, HI
IT, KO, PA, PT, RU, TA, TL, UK, UR, VI, ZH
Send a Message to: Vagans Legal

NOTE: Do not send confidential details about your case.  Using this website does not establish a legal-representative/client relationship.  Use the website for your introduction with Vagans Legal. 
Privacy Policy & Cookies | Terms of Use Your IP Address is: 18.97.14.81
Vagans Legal

1504 Markham Road
Scarborough, Ontario,
M1B 2V9
 
P: (416) 473-8472
E: info@vaganslegal.com

Business Hours:

09:00AM - 05:00PM
09:00AM - 05:00PM
09:00AM - 05:00PM
09:00AM - 05:00PM
09:00AM - 05:00PM
Monday:
Tuesday:
Wednesday:
Thursday:
Friday:

By appointment only.  Call for details.
Messages may be left anytime.

Application Hosted on Microsoft Azure Cloud Web Servers | Analytics by Google
Let’s Encrypt SSL certificate is a service provided by the Internet Security Research Group (ISRG)
All names, logos and/or trademarks are those of their respective owners.

The web-server required 2.03 seconds at 5% CPU use to assimilate datapoints for this webpage.
In-Process SessionID: 35625865 | Out-of-Process SessionID:
This webpage was served on: November 08 2026 at 08:51:41PM Eastern.

.








Assistive Controls:  |   |  A A A